|
The Vietnam War, also known as
the Second
Indochina
War, or the Vietnam
Conflict, occurred in
Vietnam,
Laos
and
Cambodia
from 1959[1]
to April 30, 1975. The war was
fought between the communist
North
Vietnam, supported by
its communist allies, and the
government of
South
Vietnam, supported by
the United States and other
member nations of the
Southeast
Asia Treaty Organization
(SEATO).[9][10]
The
Vietcong,
the lightly armed South
Vietnamese
communist
insurgency,
largely fought a
guerrilla
war against
anti-communist forces
in the region. The
North
Vietnamese Army
engaged in a more
conventional war, at
times committing large-sized
units into battle. U.S. and
South Vietnamese forces relied
on
air
superiority and
overwhelming firepower to
conduct
search-and-destroy
operations, involving
ground
forces,
artillery
and
air
strikes.
The
United States entered the war to
prevent a communist takeover of
South Vietnam as part of a wider
strategy called
containment.
Military
advisors arrived
beginning in 1950. U.S.
involvement escalated in the
early 1960s and
combat
units were deployed
beginning in 1965. Involvement
peaked in 1968 at the time of
the
Tet
Offensive. Under a
policy called
Vietnamization, U.S.
forces withdrew as South
Vietnamese troops were trained
and armed. Despite a
peace
treaty signed by all
parties in January 1973,
fighting continued. In response
to the
anti-war
movement, the U.S.
Congress passed the
Case-Church Amendment
in June 1973 prohibiting further
U.S. military intervention. In
April 1975, North Vietnam
captured
Saigon. North and
South Vietnam were reunified the
following year.
The
war had a major impact on U.S.
politics, culture and
foreign
relations. Americans
were deeply divided over the
U.S. government’s justification
for, and means of fighting, the
war. Opposition to the war
contributed to the
counterculture youth
movement of the 1960s and the
war contributed towards youth
cynicism towards actions of the
government.
The war exacted a
huge human cost in terms of
fatalities, including 3 to 4
million Vietnamese from both
sides, 1.5 to 2 million
Laotians
and
Cambodians,
and 58,159 U.S. soldiers.[11]
Back Top
-
Various names
have been applied to the
conflict. Vietnam War is the
most commonly used name in
English.
It has also been called the
Second Indochina War, and the
Vietnam Conflict. In
Vietnamese,
the war is known as Chiến
tranh Việt Nam (The Vietnam
War), or as Kháng chiến chống
Mỹ (Resistance War Against
America), loosely translated as
the American War.[12]
As there have been so many
conflicts in Indochina, this
conflict is known by the names
of their chief opponent to
distinguish it from the others.[13]
The
main military organizations
involved in the war were, on the
side of the South, the U.S.
military and the
Army of
the Republic of Vietnam
(ARVN), and, on the side of the
North, the
Vietnam
People's Army (VPA),
also known as the North
Vietnamese Army (NVA) also
called the People's Army of
Vietnam (PAVN), and the
Vietcong,
or National Front for the
Liberation of South Vietnam (NLF),
a communist army based in the
South.
Back Top
Exit
of the French, 1950–1954
-
Main
articles:
First
Indochina War,
International Control
Commission
Truman
and the Vietnam War
(1945-1953) and
Eisenhower and the Vietnam
War (1953-1961)
In January 1950,
the communist nations, led by
the People's Republic of China,
recognized the Vietminh's
Democratic
Republic of Vietnam
as the government of Vietnam.
Non-Communist nations recognized
the French-backed
State of
Vietnam in Saigon led
by former Emperor
Bao Dai
the following month.[14]
The outbreak of the
Korean War
in June 1950 convinced many
Washington policymakers that the
war in Indochina was an example
of communist expansionism
directed by the
Kremlin.[15]
The communist
takeover of China in 1949
revived the fortunes of the
Vietminh.[16]
P. R. Chinese military advisors
began assisting the Vietminh in
July 1950.[17]
P. R. Chinese weapons,
expertise, and laborers
transformed the Vietminh from a
guerrilla force into a regular
army.[16]
In September, the U.S. created a
Military
Assistance and Advisory Group
(MAAG) to screen French requests
for aid, advise on strategy, and
train Vietnamese soldiers.[18]
By 1954, the U.S. had supplied
300,000 small arms and spent
US$1 billion in support of the
French military effort and was
shouldering 80 percent of the
cost of the war.[19]
The Vietminh received crucial
support from the Soviet Union
and P. R. China. P. R. Chinese
support in the
Border
Campaign of 1950
allowed supplies to come from P.
R. China into Vietnam.
Throughout the conflict, U.S.
intelligence estimates remained
skeptical of French chances of
success.[20]
The
Battle of
Dien Bien Phu marked
the end of French involvement in
Indochina. The Viet Minh and
their mercurial commander
Vo Nguyen
Giap handed the
French a stunning military
defeat. France had earlier
declined the American offer of
nuclear
weapons to break the
Vietnamese siege[21]
and on May 7, 1954, the
French
Union garrison
surrendered. At the
Geneva
Conference the French
negotiated a ceasefire agreement
with the Viet Minh. Independence
was granted to
Cambodia,
Laos
and Vietnam.
-
Vietnam was
temporarily partitioned at the
17th
parallel, and under
the terms of the Geneva
Convention, civilians were to be
given the opportunity to freely
move between the two provisional
states. Elections throughout the
country were to be held,
according to the Geneva accords,
but were blocked by The South
Vietnamese president, who feared
a communist victory.[22]
Around one million northerners,
mainly Catholics, fled south,
fearing persecution by the
communists,[23]
following an American campaign
of "psychological warfare"[24]
using slogans such as, "The
Virgin Mary is heading south",[24]
and aided by a U.S. funded $93
million relocation program,
which included ferrying refugees
with the Seventh Fleet.[25]
It is estimated that as many as
two million more would have left
had they not been stopped by the
Vietminh.[26]
In the north, the Vietminh
established a
socialist
state—the
Democratic
Republic of Vietnam—and
engaged in a drastic land reform
program in which an estimated
eight thousand perceived “class
enemies” were executed.[27]
In 1956 the Communist Party
leaders of Hanoi admitted to
"excesses" in implementing this
program and restored a lot of
the land to the original owners.[28]
In the south a non-communist
state was established under the
Emperor Bao Dai, a former puppet
of the French and the Japanese.
Ngô Đình
Diệm became his prime
minister. In addition to the
Catholics flowing south, up to
130,000 ‘Revolutionary
Regroupees’, went north for
“regroupment” expecting to
return to the South within 2
years.[29]
The Vietminh left roughly 5,000
to 10,000
cadres
in South Vietnam as a
“politico-military substructure
within the object of its
irredentism.”[30]
The last French soldiers left
Vietnam in April 1956.[16]
The P. R. Chinese completed
their withdrawal from North
Vietnam at around the same time.[17]
Back Top
-
Main
article:
Ngo Dinh Diem
The
Geneva
Accords, concluded
between France and the Vietminh
in 1954, partitioned Vietnam on
a temporary basis pending
national elections to be held by
July 20, 1956.[31]
Much as in
Korea,
the agreement stipulated that
the two military zones were to
be separated by a temporary
demarcation line (known as the
Demilitarized Zone or
DMZ) In June 1955, Prime
Minister
Ngo Dinh
Diem of the State of
Vietnam (then occupying South
Vietnam) announced that
elections would not be held.
South Vietnam had rejected the
agreement from the beginning, he
said. "How can we expect 'free
elections' to be held in the
Communist North?" Diem asked.
President Dwight D. Eisenhower
expressed U.S. fears when he
wrote that, in 1954, “80 per
cent of the population would
have voted for the Communist Ho
Chi Minh” over Emperor Bao Dai.[32][33]
However, this wide popularity
was expressed before Ho's land
reform program and the
suppression of a peasant revolt
in Ho's home province,[citation
needed]
and Diem's imprisonment of
20,000 communists in reeducation
camps,[34]
and the
Buddhist
crisis in the south.
The
Domino
Theory, which argued
that if one country fell to
communist forces, then all of
the surrounding countries would
follow, was first proposed as
policy by the Eisenhower
administration.[35]
It was, and is still, commonly
hypothesized that it applied to
Viet Nam. John F. Kennedy, then
a U.S. senator, said in a speech
to the American Friends of
Vietnam: "Burma, Thailand,
India, Japan, the Philippines
and obviously Laos and Cambodia
are among those whose security
would be threatened if the Red
Tide of Communism overflowed
into Vietnam.".[36]
Back Top
-
Ngo Dinh Diem
was named premier of South
Vietnam in 1954 by former
emperor and Head of State Bao
Dai. A devout
Roman
Catholic, he was
fervently anti-communist and was
“untainted” by any connection to
the French. He was one of the
few prominent Vietnamese
nationalists who could claim
both attributes. Historian Luu
Doan Huynh notes, however, that
“Diem represented narrow and
extremist nationalism coupled
with autocracy and
nepotism.”[37]
The new American
patrons were almost completely
ignorant of Vietnamese culture.
They knew little of the language
or long history of the country.[14]
There was a tendency to assign
American motives to Vietnamese
actions, and Diem warned that it
was an illusion to believe that
blindly copying Western methods
would solve Vietnamese problems.[14]
In April and June
1955, Diem (against U.S. advice)
cleared the decks of any
political opposition by
launching military operations
against the
Cao Dai
religious sect, the Buddhist
Hoa Hao,
and the
Binh Xuyen
organized crime group (which was
allied with members of the
secret police and some military
elements). Diem accused these
groups of harboring Communist
agents. As broad-based
opposition to his harsh tactics
mounted, Diem increasingly
sought to blame the communists.[38]
Beginning in the
summer of 1955, he launched the
“Denounce the Communists”
campaign, during which
communists and other
anti-government elements were
arrested, imprisoned, tortured,
or executed. Opponents were
labeled
Viet Cong
by the regime to degrade their
nationalist credentials. During
this period refugees moved
across the demarcation line in
both directions. Around 52,000
Vietnamese civilians moved from
south to north. However, 800,000
people fled north Vietnam to the
south, mostly in aircraft and
ships provided by France and the
U.S.[39]
CIA propaganda efforts increased
the outflow with slogans such as
“the Virgin Mary is going
South.” The northern refugees
were meant to give Diem a strong
anti-communist constituency.[40]
In a referendum
on the future of the monarchy,
Diem
rigged
the poll supervised by his
brother
Ngo Dinh
Nhu and was
accredited with 98.2 percent of
the vote, including 133% in
Saigon. His American advisers
had recommended a more modest
winning margin of “60 to 70
percent.” Diem, however, viewed
the election as a test of
authority.[41]
On October 26, 1955, Diem
declared the new Republic of
Vietnam, with himself as
president.[42]
The Republic of Vietnam was
created largely because of the
Eisenhower administration's
desire for an anti-communist
state in the region.[38]
As a
wealthy Catholic, Diem was
viewed by many ordinary
Vietnamese as part of the old
elite who had helped the French
rule Vietnam. The majority of
Vietnamese people were Buddhist,
so his attack on the Buddhist
community served only to deepen
mistrust.
In May, Diem
undertook a ten-day state visit
to the United States. President
Eisenhower pledged his continued
support. A parade in
New York
City was held in his
honor. Although Diem was openly
praised, in private
Secretary
of State
John
Foster Dulles
conceded that he had been
selected because there were no
better alternatives.[43]
Back Top
-
The
Sino-Soviet split led
to a reduction in the influence
of P. R. China, which had
insisted in 1954 that the
Vietminh accept a division of
the country.
Trường
Chinh, North
Vietnam's pro-P. R. Chinese
party first secretary, was
demoted and Hanoi authorized
communists in South Vietnam to
begin a low level
insurgency
in December 1956.[44]
This insurgency in the south had
begun in response to Diem's
Denunciation of Communists
campaign, in which thousands of
local Viet Minh cadres and
supporters had been executed or
sent to concentration camps, and
was in violation of the Northern
Communist party line which had
enjoined them not to start an
insurrection, but rather engage
in a political campaign,
agitating for a free all-Vietnam
election in accordance with the
Geneva accords.[45]
Ho Chi Minh stated, "Do not
engage in military operations;
that will lead to defeat. Do not
take land from a peasant.
Emphasize nationalism rather
than communism. Do not
antagonize anyone if you can
avoid it. Be selective in your
violence. If an assassination is
necessary, use a knife, not a
rifle or grenade. It is too easy
to kill innocent bystanders with
guns and bombs, and accidental
killing of the innocent
bystanders will alienate
peasants from the revolution.
Once an assassination has taken
place, make sure peasants know
why the killing occurred.” This
strategy was referred to as
"armed propaganda."[46]
Soon afterward,
Lê Duẩn,
a communist leader who had been
working in the South, returned
to Hanoi to accept the position
of acting first secretary,
effectively replacing Trường.
Duẩn urged a military line and
advocated increased assistance
to the insurgency.
Four hundred
government officials were
assassinated in 1957 alone, and
the violence gradually
increased. While the terror was
originally aimed at local
government officials, it soon
broadened to include other
symbols of the status quo,
such as schoolteachers, health
workers, and agricultural
officials.[47]
One estimate says that by 1958,
20 percent of South Vietnam's
village chiefs had been murdered
by the insurgents.[48]
The insurgency sought to
completely destroy government
control in South Vietnam's rural
villages and replace it with a
shadow
government.[49]
Finally, in January 1959, the
North's Central Committee issued
a secret resolution authorizing
an "armed struggle". This
authorized the southern
communist to begin large-scale
operations against the South
Vietnamese military. However,
North Vietnam supplied troops
and supplies in earnest, and the
infiltration of men and weapons
from the north began along the
Ho Chi
Minh Trail. In May,
South Vietnam enacted Law 10/59,
which made political violence
punishable by death and property
confiscation.[50]
Observing the increasing
unpopularity of the Diem regime,
on December 12, 1960,
Hanoi
authorized the creation of the
National
Liberation Front as a
front group for the Vietcong,
the communist army in the South.
Successive
American administrations, as
Robert McNamara and others have
noted, overestimated the control
that Hanoi had over the NLF.[14]
Diem's paranoia, repression, and
incompetence progressively
angered large segments of the
population of South Vietnam.[51]
Thus, many maintain that the
origins of the anti-government
violence were homegrown, rather
than inspired by Hanoi.[52]
Historian
Douglas
Pike asserts that,
“today, no serious historian
would defend the thesis that
North Vietnam was not involved
in the Vietnam war from the
start.... To maintain this
thesis today, one would be
obliged to deal with the
assertions of Northern
involvement that have poured out
of Hanoi since the end of the
war."[53]
Back Top
-
When
John F.
Kennedy won the
1960 U.S.
presidential election,
one major issue Kennedy raised
was whether the Soviet space and
missile programs had surpassed
those of the U.S. As Kennedy
took over, despite warnings from
Eisenhower about Laos and
Vietnam, Europe and Latin
America "loomed larger than Asia
on his sights."[54]
In his inaugural address,
Kennedy made the ambitious
pledge to "pay any price, bear
any burden, meet any hardship,
support any friend, oppose any
foe, in order to assure the
survival and success of
liberty."[55]
In
June 1961, John F. Kennedy
bitterly disagreed with Soviet
premier Nikita Khrushchev when
they met in Vienna over key
U.S.-Soviet issues. The
Legacy of
the Korean War
created the idea of a limited
war.
Although Kennedy stressed
long-range missile parity with
the Soviets, he was also
interested in using special
forces for counterinsurgency
warfare in Third World countries
threatened by communist
insurgencies. Although they were
originally intended for use
behind front lines after a
conventional invasion of Europe,
Kennedy believed that the
guerrilla tactics employed by
special forces such as the
Green
Berets would be
effective in a "brush fire" war
in Vietnam.
The Kennedy
administration remained
essentially committed to the
Cold War
foreign policy inherited from
the Truman and Eisenhower
administrations. In 1961, the
USA had 50,000 troops based in
Korea, and Kennedy faced a
three-part crisis—the failure of
the
Bay of
Pigs invasion, the
construction of the
Berlin
Wall, and a
negotiated settlement between
the pro-Western government of
Laos and the
Pathet Lao
communist movement[56]
These made Kennedy believe that
another failure on the part of
the United States to gain
control and stop communist
expansion would fatally damage
U.S. credibility with its allies
and his own reputation. Kennedy
determined to "draw a line in
the sand" and prevent a
communist victory in Vietnam,
saying, "Now we have a problem
making our power credible and
Vietnam looks like the place,"
to James Reston of
The New
York Times
immediately after meeting
Khrushchev in Vienna.[57][58]
In
May 1961, Vice President
Lyndon B.
Johnson visited
Saigon and enthusiastically
declared Diem the "Winston
Churchill of Asia."[59]
Asked why he had made the
comment, Johnson replied,
"Diem's the only boy we got out
there."[43]
Johnson assured Diem of more aid
in molding a fighting force that
could resist the communists.
Kennedy's policy
toward South Vietnam rested on
the assumption that Diem and his
forces must ultimately defeat
the guerrillas on their own. He
was against the deployment of
American combat troops and
observed that "to introduce U.S.
forces in large numbers there
today, while it might have an
initially favorable military
impact, would almost certainly
lead to adverse political and,
in the long run, adverse
military consequences."[60]
South Vietnam,
Military Regions,
1967
The quality of
the South Vietnamese military,
however, remained poor. Bad
leadership, corruption, and
political interference all
played a part in emasculating
the
Army of
the Republic of Vietnam
(ARVN). The frequency of
guerrilla attacks rose as the
insurgency gathered steam.
Hanoi's support for the NLF
played a significant role. But
South Vietnamese governmental
incompetence was at the core of
the crisis.[61]
Kennedy advisers
Maxwell
Taylor and
Walt
Rostow recommended
that U.S. troops be sent to
South Vietnam disguised as flood
relief workers. Kennedy rejected
the idea but increased military
assistance yet again. In April
1962,
John
Kenneth Galbraith
warned Kennedy of the "danger we
shall replace the French as a
colonial force in the area and
bleed as the French did."[62]
Because of vast Dutch oil
discoveries in nearby
Indonesia,
first the French, then the
Americans, wanted to explore the
broad Vietnamese continental
shelf.[63]
By 1963, there were 16,000
American military personnel in
South Vietnam, up from
Eisenhower's 900 advisors.[64]
The
Strategic
Hamlet Program had
been initiated in 1961. This
joint U.S.-South Vietnamese
program attempted to resettle
the rural population into
fortified camps. The aim was to
isolate the population from the
insurgents, provide education
and health care, and strengthen
the government's hold over the
countryside. The Strategic
Hamlets, however, were quickly
infiltrated by the guerrillas.
The peasants resented being
uprooted from their ancestral
villages. The government refused
to undertake land reform, which
left farmers paying high rents
to a few wealthy landlords.
Corruption dogged the program
and intensified opposition.
Government officials were
targeted for assassination.
On July 23, 1962,
fourteen nations, including the
People's Republic of China,
South Vietnam, the Soviet Union,
North Vietnam and the United
States, signed an agreement
promising the neutrality of
Laos.[65]
Back Top
-
See also:
Kennedy's role,
Kennedy and Vietnam,
Hue
Vesak shootings
and
Xa Loi Pagoda raids
-
The inept
performance of the South
Vietnamese army was exemplified
by failed actions such as the
Battle of
Ap Bac on January 2,
1963, in which a small band of
Viet Cong beat off a much larger
and better equipped South
Vietnamese force, many of whose
troops seemed reluctant even to
engage in combat.[66]
The ARVN were led in that battle
by Diem's most trusted General
Huynh Van
Cao, a Catholic who
had been promoted due to
religion and fidelity rather
than skill. Some policy-makers
in Washington began to conclude
that Diem was incapable of
defeating the communists and
might even make a deal with Ho
Chi Minh. He seemed concerned
only with fending off coups. As
Robert F.
Kennedy noted, "Diem
wouldn't make even the slightest
concessions. He was difficult to
reason with..."[67]
Discontent with Diem's policies
exploded following the
Hue Vesak
shootings of majority
Buddhists who were protesting
against the ban on the
Buddhist
flag on
Vesak,
the Buddha's birthday. This
resulted in mass protests
against policies that gave
privileges to the Catholic
Church and its adherents. Diem
refused to make concessions to
the Buddhist majority or take
responsibility for the deaths.
On August 21, the
ARVN
Special Forces of
Colonel
Le Quang
Tung, loyal to Diem's
younger brother
Ngo Dinh
Nhu, raided pagodas
across Vietnam, causing
widespread damage and
destruction.
During the summer of 1963 U.S.
officials began discussing the
possibility of a regime change.
The
United
States Department of State
was generally in favor of
encouraging a
coup.
Chief among the proposed changes
was the removal of Diem's
younger brother
Ngo Dinh
Nhu. Nhu controlled
the secret police and was seen
as the man behind the Buddhist
repression. As Diem's most
powerful adviser, Nhu had become
a hated figure in South Vietnam.
The CIA was in
contact with generals planning
to remove Diem. They were told
that the United States would not
oppose such a move nor punish
the generals by cutting off aid.
President Diem was overthrown
and executed, along with his
brother, on November 2, 1963.
When he was informed, Maxwell
Taylor remembered that Kennedy
"rushed from the room with a
look of shock and dismay on his
face."[68]
He had not approved Diem's
murder. The U.S. ambassador to
South Vietnam,
Henry
Cabot Lodge, invited
the coup leaders to the embassy
and congratulated them.
Ambassador Lodge informed
Kennedy that "the prospects now
are for a shorter war".[69]
Following the
coup, chaos ensued. Hanoi took
advantage of the situation and
increased its support for the
guerrillas. South Vietnam
entered a period of extreme
political instability, as one
military government toppled
another in quick succession.
Increasingly, each new regime
was viewed as a puppet of the
Americans; whatever the failings
of Diem, his credentials as a
nationalist (as Robert McNamara
later reflected) had been
impeccable.[70]
U.S military
advisers were embedded at every
level of the South Vietnamese
armed forces. They were,
however, almost completely
ignorant of the political nature
of the
insurgency.
The insurgency was a political
power struggle, in which
military engagements were not
the main goal.[71]
The Kennedy administration
sought to refocus U.S. efforts
on
pacification and
"winning over the hearts and
minds" of the population. The
military leadership in
Washington, however, was hostile
to any role for U.S. advisers
other than conventional troop
training.[72]
General
Paul
Harkins, the
commander of U.S. forces in
South Vietnam, confidently
predicted victory by Christmas
1963.[73]
The CIA was less optimistic,
however, warning that "the Viet
Cong by and large retain de
facto control of much of the
countryside and have steadily
increased the overall intensity
of the effort".[74]
In a
conversation with
Nobel
Peace Prize winner
and Canadian prime minister
Lester B.
Pearson, Kennedy
sought his advice. "Get out,"
Pearson replied. "That's a
stupid answer," shot back
Kennedy. "Everyone knows that.
The question is: How do we get
out?"[75]
Kennedy
was assassinated on
November 22, 1963, just three
weeks after Diem.
Kennedy had introduced
helicopters to the war and
created a joint U.S.-South
Vietnamese Air Force, staffed
with American pilots. He also
sent in the
Green
Berets. He was
succeeded by his vice president,
Lyndon B. Johnson, who
reaffirmed America's support of
South Vietnam.
Back Top
-
For more
details on this topic, see
Americanization
-
See also:
Opposition to the Vietnam
War and
Gulf of Tonkin Incident
A U.S. EB-66
Destroyer and four
F-105 Thunderchiefs
dropping bombs on
North Vietnam
An alleged NLF
activist, captured
during an attack on
an
American
outpost near the
Cambodian
border, is
interrogated.
Lyndon B. Johnson
(LBJ), as he took over the
presidency after the death of
Kennedy, did not consider
Vietnam a priority and was more
concerned with his "Great
Society" and
progressive social programs.
Presidential aid Jack Valenti
recalls, "Vietnam at the time
was no bigger than a man's fist
on the horizon. We hardly
discussed it because it was not
worth discussing."[76][77]
On November 24,
1963, Johnson said, "the battle
against communism... must be
joined... with strength and
determination."[78]
The pledge came at a time when
Vietnam was deteriorating,
especially in places like the
Mekong Delta, because of the
recent coup against Diem.[79]
The military
revolutionary council, meeting
in lieu of a strong South
Vietnamese leader, was made up
of 12 members headed by General
Minh—whom
Stanley
Karnow, a journalist
on the ground, later recalled as
"a model of lethargy."[80]
His regime was overthrown in
January 1964 by General Nguyen
Khanh. Lodge, frustrated by the
end of year, cabled home about
Minh: "Will he be strong enough
to get on top of things?"[81]
On August 2,
1964, the
USS
Maddox,
on an intelligence mission along
North Vietnam's coast, fired
upon and damaged several torpedo
boats that had been stalking it
in the
Gulf of
Tonkin.[82]
A second attack was reported two
days later on the
USS
Turner
Joy and Maddox
in the same area. The
circumstances of the attack were
murky. Lyndon Johnson commented
to Undersecretary of State
George Ball that "those sailors
out there may have been shooting
at flying fish."[83]
The second attack led to
retaliatory air strikes,
prompted Congress to approve the
Gulf of
Tonkin Resolution,
and gave the president power to
conduct military operations in
Southeast Asia without declaring
war. In the same month, Johnson
pledged that he was not
"... committing American boys to
fighting a war that I think
ought to be fought by the boys
of Asia to help protect their
own land."[84]
An undated
NSA
publication declassified in
2005, however, revealed that
there was no attack on August 4.[82]
It had already been called into
question long before this.
"The Gulf
of Tonkin incident",
writes Louise Gerdes, "is an
oft-cited example of the way in
which Johnson misled the
American people to gain support
for his foreign policy in
Vietnam."[85]
George C. Herring argues,
however, that McNamara and the
Pentagon "did not knowingly lie
about the alleged attacks, but
they were obviously in a mood to
retaliate and they seem to have
selected from the evidence
available to them those parts
that confirmed what they wanted
to believe."[86]
"From a strength
of approximately 5,000 at the
start of 1959 the Viet Cong's
ranks grew to about 100,000 at
the end of 1964...Between 1961
and 1964 the Army's strength
rose from about 850,000 to
nearly a million men"[71]-The
U.S. Army in Vietnam, by
Vincent H. Demma. The numbers
for US troops deployed to Viet
Nam during the same period were
quite different; 2,000 in 1961,
rising rapidly to 16,500 in
1964.[87]
A Marine from 1st
Battalion, 3rd
Marines, moves an
alleged NLF activist
to the rear during a
search and clear
operation held by
the battalion
15 miles (24 km)
west of Da Nang Air
Base.
The
National
Security Council
recommended a three-stage
escalation of the bombing of
North Vietnam. On March 2, 1965,
following an attack on a
U.S.
Marine barracks at
Pleiku,
Operation
Flaming Dart,
Operation
Rolling Thunder and
Operation
Arc Light commenced.
The bombing campaign, which
ultimately lasted three years,
was intended to force North
Vietnam to cease its support for
the National Front for the
Liberation of South Vietnam (NLF)
by threatening to destroy North
Vietnam's air defenses and
industrial infrastructure. As
well, it was aimed at bolstering
the morale of the South
Vietnamese.[88]
Between March 1965 and November
1968, "Rolling Thunder" deluged
the north with a million tons of
missiles, rockets and bombs.[89]
Bombing was not restricted to
North Vietnam. Other aerial
campaigns, such as
Operation
Commando Hunt,
targeted different parts of the
NLF and
Vietnam
People's Army (VPA)
infrastructure. These included
the Ho Chi Minh Trail, which ran
through Laos and Cambodia. The
objective of forcing North
Vietnam to stop its support for
the NLF, however, was never
reached. As one officer noted
"this is a political war and it
calls for discriminate killing.
The best weapon... would be a
knife... The worst is an
airplane."[90]
The
Chief of
Staff of the United States Air
Force
Curtis
LeMay, however, had
long advocated saturation
bombing in Vietnam and wrote of
the Communists that "we're going
to bomb them back into the Stone
Age".[91]
Back Top
Peasants suspected
of being communists
under detention of
U.S. army, 1966
Escalation of the Vietnam War
officially started on the
morning of January 31, 1965,
when orders were cut and issued
to mobilize the 18th TAC Fighter
Squadron from
Okinawa
to
Da Nang
Air Force Base (AFB). A red
alert alarm to scramble was
sounded at
Kadena
AFB at 3:00 a.m.
F-105s,
pilots, and support were
deployed from Okinawa and landed
in Vietnam that afternoon to
join up with other smaller units
who had already arrived weeks
earlier. Preparations were under
way for the first step of
Operation Flaming Dart. The
mission of Operation Flaming
Dart, to cross the Seventeenth
Parallel into North Vietnam, had
already been planned and was in
place before the
NLF attack
on Pleiku airbase on
February 6. On February 7,
forty-nine F-105 Thunderchiefs
flew out of Danang AFB to
targets located in North
Vietnam. From this day forward
the war was no longer confined
to South Vietnam. It took almost
an hour to get all forty nine of
the F-105's in the air. On that
morning, the continuous loud
roar of the F-105 engines going
down the runway, one following
another, was described by the
ground crew as a "rolling
thunder".
After several
attacks upon them, it was
decided that
U.S. Air
Force bases needed
more protection. The South
Vietnamese military seemed
incapable of providing security.
On March 8, 1965, 3,500 United
States Marines were dispatched
to South Vietnam. This marked
the beginning of the American
ground war. U.S. public opinion
overwhelmingly supported the
deployment.[92]
Public opinion, however, was
based on the premise that
Vietnam was part of a global
struggle against communism. In a
statement similar to that made
to the French almost two decades
earlier, Ho Chi Minh warned that
if the Americans "want to make
war for twenty years then we
shall make war for twenty years.
If they want to make peace, we
shall make peace and invite them
to afternoon tea."[93]
As former First Deputy Foreign
Minister Tran Quang Co has
noted, the primary goal of the
war was to reunify Vietnam and
secure its independence. The
policy of the Democratic
Republic of Vietnam (DRV) was
not to topple other
non-communist governments in
South East Asia.[94]
The
Marines' assignment was
defensive. The initial
deployment of 3,500 in March was
increased to nearly 200,000 by
December.[95]
The U.S. military had long been
schooled in offensive warfare.
Regardless of political
policies, U.S. commanders were
institutionally and
psychologically unsuited to a
defensive mission.[95]
In May, Army of the Republic of
Vietnam (ARVN) forces suffered
heavy losses at the
Battle of
Binh Gia. They were
again defeated in June, at the
Battle of
Dong Xoai. Desertion
rates were increasing, and
morale plummeted. General
William
Westmoreland informed
Admiral
Grant
Sharp, commander of
U.S. Pacific forces, that the
situation was critical.[95]
He said, "I am convinced that
U.S. troops with their energy,
mobility, and firepower can
successfully take the fight to
the NLF [National Front for the
Liberation of South Vietnam]."[96]
With this recommendation,
Westmoreland was advocating an
aggressive departure from
America's defensive posture and
the sidelining of the South
Vietnamese. By ignoring ARVN
units, the U.S. commitment
became open-ended.[97]
Westmoreland outlined a
three-point plan to win the war:
U.S.
soldiers searching a
village for
NLF
"Phase 1. Commitment of U.S.
(and other free world) forces
necessary to halt the losing
trend by the end of 1965.
Phase 2. U.S. and allied forces
mount major offensive actions to
seize the initiative to destroy
guerrilla and organized enemy
forces. This phase would be
concluded when the enemy had
been worn down, thrown on the
defensive, and driven back from
major populated areas.
Phase 3. If the
enemy persisted, a period of
twelve to eighteen months
following Phase 2 would be
required for the final
destruction of enemy forces
remaining in remote base areas."[98]
The plan was
approved by Johnson and marked a
profound departure from the
previous administration's
insistence that the government
of South Vietnam was responsible
for defeating the guerrillas.
Westmoreland predicted victory
by the end of 1967.[99]
Johnson did not, however,
communicate this change in
strategy to the media. Instead
he emphasized continuity.[100]
The change in U.S. policy
depended on matching the North
Vietnamese and the NLF in a
contest of
attrition
and
morale.
The opponents were locked in a
cycle of
escalation.[101]
The idea that the government of
South Vietnam could manage its
own affairs was shelved.[101]
Members of U.S. Navy
SEAL Team One move
down the Bassac
River in a Seal team
Assault Boat (STAB)
during operations
along the river
south of Saigon,
November 1967.
It
is widely held that the average
U.S. serviceman was nineteen
years old, as evidenced by the
casual reference in a pop song (19
by
Paul
Hardcastle); the
figure is cited by
Lt. Col.
Dave
Grossman ret. of the
Killology
Research Group in his
1995 book
On
Killing: The Psychological Cost
of Learning to Kill in War and
Society (p. 265).
However, it is disputed by the[102]
Vietnam Helicopter Flight Crew
Network Website, which claims
the average age of MOS 11B
personnel was 22. This compares
with twenty-six years of age for
those who participated in World
War II. Soldiers served a one
year tour of duty. The average
age of the US Military men who
died in Vietnam was 22.8 years
old.[103]
The one-year tour of duty
deprived units of experienced
leadership. As one observer
noted "we were not in Vietnam
for 10 years, but for one year
10 times."[90]
As a result, training programs
were shortened. Some
NCOs
were referred to as "Shake
'N' Bake" to
highlight their accelerated
training. Unlike soldiers in
World War II and Korea, there
were no secure rear areas in
which to get rest and relaxation
(R'n'R).
The Ho Chi Minh
Trail running
through Laos, 1967
South Vietnam was inundated with
manufactured goods. As Stanley
Karnow writes, "the main PX,
located in the Saigon suburb of
Cholon,
was only slightly smaller than
the
New York
Bloomingdale's..."[104]
The American buildup transformed
the economy and had a profound
impact on South Vietnamese
society. A huge surge in
corruption was witnessed.
Washington encouraged its
SEATO
allies to contribute troops.
Australia,
New
Zealand, the
Republic
of Korea,
Thailand,
and the
Philippines[105]
all agreed to send troops. Major
allies, however, notably
NATO
nations, Canada and the United
Kingdom, declined Washington's
troop requests.[106]
The U.S. and its allies mounted
complex operations, such as
operations
Masher,
Attleboro,
Cedar
Falls, and
Junction
City. However, the
communist insurgents remained
elusive and demonstrated great
tactical
flexibility.
Meanwhile, the political
situation in South Vietnam began
to stabilize somewhat with the
coming to power of Vice
President
Nguyen Cao
Ky and President
Nguyen Van
Thieu in 1967. Thieu,
mistrustful and indecisive,
remained president until 1975.[107]
This ended a long series of
military
juntas
that had begun with Diem's
assassination. The relative calm
allowed the ARVN to collaborate
more effectively with its allies
and become a better fighting
force.
The Johnson
administration employed a
"policy of minimum candor"[108]
in its dealings with the media.
Military information officers
sought to manage media coverage
by emphasizing stories which
portrayed progress in the war.
Over time, this policy damaged
the public trust in official
pronouncements. As the media's
coverage of the war and that of
the Pentagon diverged, a
so-called
credibility gap
developed.[108]
In October 1967 a
large anti-war demonstration was
held on the steps of the
Pentagon. Of the thousands of
protesters, over 680 were
arrested. Some protesters
chanted phrases like, “Ho, Ho,
Ho Chi Minh! The NLF is going to
win!”[109]
and "Hey, hey, LBJ! How many
boys did you kill today?"[110]
Back Top
-
Main
article:
Tet Offensive
Having lured General
Westmoreland's forces into the
hinterland at
Khe Sanh
in
Quang Tri
Province,[111]
in January 1968, the PVA and NLF
broke the truce that had
traditionally accompanied the
Tết
(Lunar New Year) holiday. They
launched the surprise Tet
Offensive in the hope of
sparking a national uprising.
Over 100 cities were attacked,
with assaults on General
Westmoreland's headquarters and
the U.S. embassy in Saigon.
Although the U.S. and South
Vietnamese were initially taken
aback by the scale of the urban
offensive, they responded
quickly and effectively,
decimating the ranks of the NLF.
In the former capital city of
Huế,
the combined NLF and
NVA
troops captured the Imperial
Citadel and much of the city,
which led to the
Battle of
Hue. During the
interim between the capture of
the Citadel and end of the
"Battle of Hue", the communist
insurgent occupying forces
massacred
several thousand unarmed Hue
civilians (estimates vary up to
a high of 6000). After the war,
North Vietnamese officials
acknowledged that the Tet
Offensive had, indeed, caused
grave damage to NLF forces. But
the offensive had another,
unintended consequence.
General
Westmoreland had become the
public face of the war. He was
featured on the cover of Time
magazine three times and was
named 1965's Man of the Year.[112]
Time described him as
"the sinewy personification of
the American fighting man...
(who) directed the historic
buildup, drew up the battle
plans, and infused the... men
under him with his own
idealistic view of U.S. aims and
responsibilities."[112]
In November 1967
Westmoreland spearheaded a
public relations drive for the
Johnson administration to
bolster flagging public support.[113]
In a speech before the
National
Press Club he said
that a point in the war had been
reached "where the end comes
into view."[114]
Thus, the public was shocked and
confused when Westmoreland's
predictions were trumped by Tet.[113]
The American media, which had
been largely supportive of U.S.
efforts, rounded on the Johnson
administration for what had
become an increasing credibility
gap. Despite its military
failure, the Tet Offensive
became a political victory and
ended the career of President
Lyndon B. Johnson, who declined
to run for re-election.
Johnson's approval rating
slumped from 48 to 36 percent.[113]
As James Witz noted, Tet
"contradicted the claims of
progress... made by the Johnson
administration and the
military."[113]
The Tet Offensive was the
turning point in America's
involvement in the Vietnam War.
It had a profound impact on
domestic support for the
conflict. The offensive
constituted an
intelligence failure
on the scale of
Pearl
Harbor.[115][116]
Journalist
Peter
Arnett quoted an
unnamed officer, saying of
Ben Tre
that "it became necessary to
destroy the village in order to
save it" (though the
authenticity of this quote is
disputed).[117]
NLF/NVA killed by
U.S. air force
personnel during an
attack on the
perimeter of Tan Son
Nhut Air Base during
the Tet Offensive
Westmoreland became Chief of
Staff of the Army in March, just
as all resistance was finally
subdued. The move was
technically a promotion.
However, his position had become
untenable because of the
offensive and because his
request for 200,000 additional
troops had been leaked to the
media. Westmoreland was
succeeded by his deputy
Creighton
Abrams, a commander
less inclined to public media
pronouncements.
On
May 10, 1968, despite low
expectations,
peace
talks began between
the U.S. and the Democratic
Republic of Vietnam.
Negotiations stagnated for five
months, until Johnson gave
orders to halt the bombing of
North Vietnam. The
Democratic
candidate, Vice President
Hubert
Humphrey, was running
against
Republican
former vice president
Richard
Nixon. Through an
intermediary,
Anna
Chennault, Nixon
advised Saigon to refuse to
participate in the talks until
after elections, claiming that
he would give them a better deal
once elected. Thieu obliged,
leaving almost no progress made
by the time Johnson left office.
As historian
Robert Dallek writes, "Lyndon
Johnson's escalation of the war
in Vietnam divided Americans
into warring camps... cost
30,000 American lives by the
time he left office, (and)
destroyed Johnson's
presidency..."[118]
His refusal to send more U.S.
troops to Vietnam was seen as
Johnson's admission that the war
was lost.[119]
It can be seen that the refusal
was a tacit admission that the
war could not be won by
escalation, at least not at a
cost acceptable to the American
people.[119]
As Secretary of Defense Robert
McNamara noted, "the dangerous
illusion of victory by the
United States was therefore
dead."[120]
It has been suggested that the
refusal was too politically
hazardous as it would have
alienated the middle classes
that were Johnson's last center
of political support (whose sons
had joined the Reserve and
National Guard to avoid service
in Vietnam.[121]
Propaganda leaflets
urging the defection
of NLF and North
Vietnamese to the
side of the Republic
of Vietnam
Back Top
-
For more
details on this topic, see
Vietnamization, 1969–1974
Severe communist losses during
the Tet Offensive allowed U.S.
President
Richard M.
Nixon to begin troop
withdrawals. His plan, called
the
Nixon
Doctrine, was to
build up the ARVN, so that they
could take over the defense of
South Vietnam. The policy became
known as "Vietnamization".
Vietnamization had much in
common with the policies of the
Kennedy administration. One
important difference, however,
remained. While Kennedy insisted
that the South Vietnamese fight
the war themselves, he attempted
to limit the scope of the
conflict.
Nixon also
pursued negotiations. Theater
commander Creighton Abrams
shifted to smaller operations,
aimed at communist logistics,
with better use of firepower and
more cooperation with the ARVN.
Nixon also began to pursue
détente
with the Soviet Union and
rapprochement with the People's
Republic of China.
This policy helped to decrease
global tensions. Détente led to
nuclear arms reduction on the
part of both
superpowers. But
Nixon was disappointed that the
PRC and the Soviet Union
continued to supply the North
Vietnamese with aid. In
September 1969, Ho Chi Minh died
at age seventy-nine.[122]
The anti-war
movement was gaining strength in
the United States. Nixon
appealed to the "silent
majority" of
Americans to support the war.
But revelations of the
My Lai
Massacre, in which a
U.S. Army
platoon
went on a rampage and raped and
killed civilians, and the 1969 “Green
Beret Affair" where
eight Special Forces soldiers,
including the 5th Special Forces
Group Commander were arrested
for the murder of a suspected
double agent[123]
provoked national and
international outrage. The
civilian cost of the war was
again questioned when the U.S.
concluded operation
Speedy
Express with a
claimed bodycount of 10,889
Communist guerillas with only 40
U.S. losses; Kevin Buckley
writing in
Newsweek
estimated that perhaps 5,000 of
the Vietnamese dead were
civilians.[124]
Back Top
Prince
Norodom
Sihanouk had
proclaimed Cambodia neutral
since 1955,[125]
but the communists used
Cambodian soil as a base and
Sihanouk tolerated their
presence, because he wished to
avoid being drawn into a wider
regional conflict. Under
pressure from Washington,
however, he changed this policy
in 1969. The Vietnamese
communists were no longer
welcome. President Nixon took
the opportunity to launch a
massive secret bombing campaign,
called
Operation
Menu, against their
sanctuaries along the border.
This violated a long succession
of pronouncements from
Washington supporting Cambodian
neutrality. Richard Nixon wrote
to Prince Sihanouk in April 1969
assuring him that the United
States respected "the
sovereignty, neutrality and
territorial integrity of the
Kingdom of Cambodia..."[126]
In 1970, Prince
Sihanouk
was deposed by his
pro-American prime minister
Lon Nol.
The country's borders were
closed, and the U.S. and ARVN
launched
incursions
into Cambodia to
attack VPA/NLF bases and buy
time for South Vietnam.
The invasion of
Cambodia sparked nationwide U.S.
protests.
Four
students were killed by National
Guardsmen at
Kent State
University during a
protest in
Ohio,
which provoked public outrage in
the United States. The reaction
to the incident by the Nixon
administration was seen as
callous and indifferent,
providing additional impetus for
the anti-war movement.[127]
In 1971 the
Pentagon
Papers were leaked to
The New
York Times. The
top-secret history of U.S.
involvement in Vietnam,
commissioned by the Department
of Defense, detailed a long
series of public deceptions. The
Supreme
Court ruled that its
publication was legal.[128]
The ARVN launched
Operation
Lam Son 719, aimed at
cutting the Ho Chi Minh trail in
Laos. The offensive was a clear
violation of Laotian neutrality,[65]
which neither side respected in
any event. Laos had long been
the scene of a
Secret War.
After meeting resistance, ARVN
forces retreated in a confused
rout. They fled along roads
littered with their own dead.
When they ran out of fuel,
soldiers abandoned their
vehicles and attempted to barge
their way on to American
helicopters sent to evacuate the
wounded. Many ARVN soldiers
clung to helicopter skids in a
desperate attempt to save
themselves. U.S. aircraft had to
destroy abandoned equipment,
including tanks, to prevent them
from falling into enemy hands.
Half of the invading ARVN troops
were either captured or killed.
The operation was a fiasco and
represented a clear failure of
Vietnamization. As Karnow noted
"the blunders were monumental...
The (South Vietnamese)
government's top officers had
been tutored by the Americans
for ten or fifteen years, many
at training schools in the
United States, yet they had
learned little."[129]
In 1971 Australia
and New Zealand withdrew their
soldiers. The U.S. troop count
was further reduced to 196,700,
with a deadline to remove
another 45,000 troops by
February 1972. As peace protests
spread across the United States,
disillusionment grew in the
ranks. Drug use increased, race
relations grew tense and the
number of soldiers disobeying
officers rose.
Fragging,
or the murder of unpopular
officers with fragmentation
grenades, increased.[130]
The Nguyen Hue
Offensive, 1972,
part of the Easter
offensive
Vietnamization was again tested
by the
Easter
Offensive of 1972, a
massive conventional invasion of
South Vietnam. The VPA and NLF
quickly overran the northern
provinces and in coordination
with other forces attacked from
Cambodia, threatening to cut the
country in half. U.S. troop
withdrawals continued. But
American airpower came to the
rescue with
Operation
Linebacker, and the
offensive was halted. However,
it became clear that without
American airpower South Vietnam
could not survive. The last
remaining American ground troops
were withdrawn in August.
Back Top
The
war was the central issue of the
1972
presidential election.
Nixon's opponent,
George
McGovern, campaigned
on a platform of withdrawal from
Vietnam. Nixon's National
Security Adviser,
Henry
Kissinger, continued
secret negotiations with North
Vietnam's
Le Duc Tho.
In October 1972, they reached an
agreement. However, South
Vietnamese President Thieu
demanded massive changes to the
peace accord. When North Vietnam
went public with the agreement's
details, the Nixon
administration claimed that the
North was attempting to
embarrass the President. The
negotiations became deadlocked.
Hanoi demanded new changes. To
show his support for South
Vietnam and force Hanoi back to
the negotiating table, Nixon
ordered
Operation
Linebacker II, a
massive bombing of Hanoi and
Haiphong. The offensive
destroyed much of the remaining
economic and industrial capacity
of North Vietnam. Simultaneously
Nixon pressured Thieu to accept
the terms of the agreement,
threatening to conclude a
bilateral peace deal and cut off
American aid.
On January 15,
1973, Nixon announced the
suspension of offensive action
against North Vietnam. The
Paris
Peace Accords on
"Ending the War and Restoring
Peace in Vietnam" were signed on
January 27, 1973, officially
ending direct U.S. involvement
in the Vietnam War. A cease-fire
was declared across North and
South Vietnam. U.S.
POWs
were released. The agreement
guaranteed the territorial
integrity of
Vietnam
and, like the
Geneva
Conference of 1954,
called for national elections in
the North and South. The Paris
Peace Accords stipulated a
sixty-day period for the total
withdrawal of U.S. forces. "This
article," noted Peter Church,
"proved... to be the only one of
the Paris Agreements which was
fully carried out."[131]
Back Top
-
Some
advocates within the peace
movement advocated a unilateral
withdrawal of U.S. forces from
Vietnam.
One reason given for the
withdrawal is that it would
contribute to a lessening of
tensions in the region and thus
less human bloodshed. Another,
contrasting reason was that the
Vietnamese should work out their
problems independent of foreign
influence.
Early opposition
to the America's involvement in
Viet Nam was centered around the
Geneva
conference of 1954
and its mandate that elections
be held to unite the country.
America's refusal to sign the
Accords, and their support of
Diem, was considered to be
thwarting the very democracy
that America claimed to be
supporting. John Kennedy, while
Senator, opposed involvement in
Viet Nam.[87]
Opposition to the Vietnam War
tended to unite groups opposed
to U.S. anti-communism,
imperialism and
colonialism and, for
those involved with the
New Left,
capitalism
itself, such as the
Catholic
Worker Movement.
Others, such as
Stephen
Spiro opposed the war
based on the theory of
Just War.
In protest to the
war, a number of Buddhists
publicly committed suicide in
high-profile
self-immolation protests.[132]
Some
critics of U.S. withdrawal
predicted that it would not
contribute to peace but rather
vastly increased bloodshed.
These critics advocated U.S.
forces remain until all threats
from the
Viet Cong
and
North
Vietnamese Army had
been eliminated.
Advocates of U.S. withdrawal
were generally known as "doves",
and they called their opponents
"hawks",
following nomenclature dating
back to the War of 1812. This
language has dated little in the
intervening years; it is still
used. The idea of a
chickenhawk refers
back to this time, to describe
those who had avoided dangerous
military
service before they
entered politics, but then
advocated aggressive stances
once in office.
High-profile opposition to the
Vietnam war turned to street
protests in an effort to turn
U.S. political opinion against
the war. The protests gained
momentum from
the Civil
Rights Movement that
had organized to oppose
segregation laws,
which had laid a foundation of
theory and infrastructure on
which the anti-war movement
grew. Protests were fueled by a
growing network of independently
published newspapers (known as
"underground papers") and the
timely advent of large venue
rock'n'roll festivals such as
Woodstock
and
Grateful
Dead shows,
attracting younger people in
search of generational
togetherness.
The
fatal
shooting of four
anti-war protesters at
Kent State
University cemented
the resolve of many protesters.
The
Kent State
killings saw campuses
erupt all across the country; in
May 1970 most universities were
strike-bound, for example at
Wayne
State University.[133]
The late 1960s in the U.S.
became a time of youth
rebellion, mass gatherings and
riots, many of which began in
response to the
assassination of Dr.
Martin
Luther King, Jr., but
which ignited in an atmosphere
of open opposition to a wartime
government.
Provocative actions by police
and by protesters turned
anti-war demonstrations in
Chicago at the
1968
Democratic National Convention
into a riot. Chicago mayor
Richard J.
Daley brought to bear
23,000 police and National
Guardsman upon 10,000
protestors.[134]
Explosive news reports of
American military abuses, such
as the 1968
My Lai
Massacre, brought new
attention and support to the
anti-war movement.
Veterans of the Vietnam War
returned home to join the
movement, including
John Kerry,
who spearheaded
Vietnam
Veterans Against the War
and testified before Congress in
televised hearings. Thirty years
later, as a United States
Senator, Kerry campaigned to
become President of the United
States, betraying a newfound
reluctance to acknowledge his
anti-war roots while playing up
his stellar war record. Other
U.S. veterans returned from the
war saying that nobody wants to
be in a war where people are
suffering and dying, but that
they found peace in their own
minds by knowing they served
their country. Some cited the
words of
George
Washington's 1790
State of
the Union Address:
"To be prepared for war is one
of the most effectual means of
preserving peace."
Anti-war protests ended with the
final withdrawal of troops after
the
Paris
Peace Accords were
signed in 1973. Momentum from
the protest organizations became
a main force for the growth of
an
environmental movement
in the United States. South
Vietnam was left to defend
itself alone when the fighting
resumed. Many South Vietnamese
fled to the United States in one
of the largest war refugee
migrations in history. There was
no peace movement to protest the
renewed bloodshed, and little
media coverage. Saigon
surrendered to the North in
1975; Laos and Cambodia were
overrun by Communist troops that
same spring.
Back Top
The U.S. and
other allied forces began
drastically reducing their troop
support in South Vietnam during
the final years of "Vietnamization".
Many U.S. troops were removed
from the region, and on March 5,
1971, the U.S. returned the
5th
Special Forces Group,
which was the first American
unit deployed to
South
Vietnam, to its
former base in
Fort Bragg,
North
Carolina.[135]
Under
Paris
Peace Accord, between
North Vietnamese Foreign
Minister
Lê Ðức Thọ
and U.S. Secretary of State
Henry
Kissinger, and
reluctantly signed by South
Vietnamese President
Thiệu,
U.S. military forces withdrew
from South Vietnam and prisoners
were exchanged. North Vietnam
was allowed to continue
supplying communist troops in
the South, but only to the
extent of replacing materials
that were consumed. Later that
year the
Nobel
Peace Prize was
awarded to Kissinger and Thọ,
but the Vietnamese negotiator
declined it saying that a true
peace did not yet exist.
The communist
leaders had expected that the
ceasefire terms would favor
their side. But Saigon,
bolstered by a surge of U.S. aid
received just before the
ceasefire went into effect,
began to roll back the Vietcong.[136]
The communists responded with a
new strategy hammered out in a
series of meetings in Hanoi in
March 1973, according to the
memoirs of
Trần Văn
Trà.[136]
As the Vietcong's top commander,
Trà participated in several of
these meetings.[136]
With U.S. bombings suspended,
work on the Ho Chi Minh Trail
and other logistical structures
could proceed unimpeded.[136]
Logistics would be upgraded
until the North was in a
position to launch a massive
invasion of the South, projected
for the 1975-76 dry season.[136]
Trà calculated that this date
would be the Hanoi's last
opportunity to strike before
Saigon's army could be fully
trained. A three-thousand-mile
long oil pipeline would be built
from North Vietnam to Vietcong
headquarters in
Loc Ninh,
about 75 miles (121 km)
northwest of Saigon.[136]
Although McGovern
himself was not elected U.S.
president, the November 1972
election did return a Democratic
majority to both houses of
Congress under McGovern's "Come
home America" campaign theme. On
March 15, 1973, U.S. President
Richard
Nixon implied that
the U.S. would intervene
militarily if the communist side
violated the ceasefire.[137]
Public and congressional
reaction to Nixon's trial
balloon was unfavorable and in
April Nixon appointed
Graham
Martin as U.S.
ambassador to Vietnam. Martin
was a second stringer compared
to previous U.S. ambassadors and
his appointment was an early
signal that Washington had given
up on Vietnam.[137]
During his confirmation hearings
in June 1973,
Secretary
of Defense
James R.
Schlesinger stated
that he would recommend
resumption of U.S. bombing in
North Vietnam if North Vietnam
launched a major offensive
against South Vietnam. On June
4, 1973, the U.S. Senate passed
the
Case-Church Amendment
to prohibit such intervention.[137]
The oil price
shock of October 1973 caused
significant damage to the South
Vietnamese economy. The Vietcong
resumed offensive operations
when dry season began and by
January 1974 it had recaptured
the territory it lost during the
previous dry season. After two
clashes that left 55 South
Vietnamese soldiers dead,
President Thiệu announced on
January 4 that the war had
restarted and that the Paris
Peace Accord was no longer in
effect. There had been over
25,000 South Vietnamese
casualties during the ceasefire
period.[138]
Gerald Ford
took over as U.S. president on
August 9, 1974 after President
Nixon resigned due to the
Watergate
scandal. At this
time, Congress cut financial aid
to South Vietnam from $1 billion
a year to $700 million. The U.S.
midterm elections in 1974
brought in a new Congress
dominated by Democrats who were
even more determined to confront
the president on the war.
Congress immediately voted in
restrictions on funding and
military activities to be phased
in through 1975 and to culminate
in a total cutoff of funding in
1976.
The
success of the 1973-74 dry
season offensive inspired Trà to
return to Hanoi in October 1974
and plead for a larger offensive
in the next dry season. This
time, Trà could travel on a
drivable highway with regular
fueling stops, a vast change
from the days was Ho Chi Minh
Trail was a dangerous mountain
trek.[139]
Giáp, the North Vietnamese
defense minister, was reluctant
to approve Trà's plan. A larger
offensive might provoke a U.S.
reaction and interfere with the
big push planned for 1976. Trà
appealed over Giáp's head to
party boss
Lê Duẩn,
who obtained Politburo approval
for the operation.
Trà's plan called for a limited
offensive from Cambodia into
Phuoc Long
Province. The strike was
designed to solve local
logistical problems, gauge the
reaction of South Vietnamese
forces, and determine whether
the U.S. would return to the
fray.
On
December 13, 1974, North
Vietnamese forces attacked Route
14 in Phouc Long Province. Phouc
Binh, the provincial capital,
fell on January 6, 1975. Ford
desperately asked Congress for
funds to assist and re-supply
the South before it was overrun.
Congress refused. The fall of
Phouc Binh and the lack of an
American response left the South
Vietnamese elite demoralized and
corruption grew rampant.
The speed of this
success led the Politburo to
reassess its strategy. It was
decided that operations in the
Central Highlands would be
turned over to General
Văn Tiến
Dũng and that Pleiku
should be seized, if possible.
Before he left for the South,
Dũng was addressed by Lê Duẩn:
"Never have we had military and
political conditions so perfect
or a strategic advantage as
great as we have now."[140]
By
1975 after the withdrawal of US
forces, the South Vietnamese
Army faced a well-organized,
highly determined and
well-funded North Vietnam. Much
of the North's material and
financial support came from the
communist bloc. Within South
Vietnam, there was increasing
chaos. Their abandonment by the
American military had
compromised an economy dependent
on U.S. financial support and
the presence of a large number
of U.S. troops. South Vietnam
suffered from the global
recession which followed the
Arab oil
embargo.
On
March 10, 1975, General Dung
launched Campaign 275, a limited
offensive into the Central
Highlands, supported by tanks
and heavy artillery. The target
was
Ban Me
Thuot, in
Daklak
Province. If the town
could be taken, the provincial
capital of
Pleiku
and the road to the coast would
be exposed for a planned
campaign in 1976. The ARVN
proved incapable of resisting
the onslaught, and its forces
collapsed on March 11. Once
again, Hanoi was surprised by
the speed of their success. Dung
now urged the Politburo to allow
him to seize Pleiku immediately
and then turn his attention to
Kontum.
He argued that with two months
of good weather remaining until
the onset of the monsoon, it
would be irresponsible to not
take advantage of the situation.
President
Nguyen Van
Thieu, a former
general, was fearful that his
forces would be cut off in the
north by the attacking
communists; Thieu ordered a
retreat. The president declared
this to be a "lighten the top
and keep the bottom" strategy.
But in what appeared to be a
repeat of
Operation
Lam Son 719, the
withdrawal soon turned into a
bloody rout. While the bulk of
ARVN forces attempted to flee,
isolated units fought
desperately. ARVN General Phu
abandoned Pleiku and Kontum and
retreated toward the coast, in
what became known as the "column
of tears". As the ARVN tried to
disengage from the enemy,
refugees mixed in with the line
of retreat. The poor condition
of roads and bridges, damaged by
years of conflict and neglect,
slowed Phu's column. As the
North Vietnamese forces
approached, panic set in. Often
abandoned by their officers, the
soldiers, and civilians, were
shelled incessantly. The retreat
degenerated into a desperate
scramble for the coast. By April
1 the "column of tears" was all
but annihilated. It marked one
of the poorest examples of a
strategic withdrawal in modern
military history.[citation
needed]}}
On
March 20, Thieu reversed himself
and ordered Hue, Vietnam's
third-largest city, be held at
all costs. Thieu's contradictory
orders confused and demoralized
his officer corps. As the North
Vietnamese launched their
attack, panic set in, and ARVN
resistance withered. On March
22, the VPA opened the siege of
Hue. Civilians flooded the
airport and the docks hoping for
any mode of escape. Some even
swam out to sea to reach boats
and barges anchored offshore. In
the confusion, routed ARVN
soldiers fired on civilians to
make way for their retreat. On
March 31, after a three-day
battle, Hue fell. As resistance
in Hue collapsed, North
Vietnamese rockets rained down
on
Da Nang
and its airport. By March 28,
35,000 VPA troops were poised to
attack the suburbs. By March 30,
100,000 leaderless ARVN troops
surrendered as the VPA marched
victoriously through Da Nang.
With the fall of the city, the
defense of the Central Highlands
and Northern provinces came to
an end.
Back Top
-
With
the northern half of the country
under their control, the
Politburo ordered General Dung
to launch the final offensive
against Saigon. The operational
plan for the
Ho Chi
Minh Campaign called
for the capture of Saigon before
May 1. Hanoi wished to avoid the
coming monsoon and prevent any
redeployment of ARVN forces
defending the capital. Northern
forces, their morale boosted by
their recent victories, rolled
on, taking Nha Trang, Cam Ranh,
and Da Lat.
On
April 7, three North Vietnamese
divisions
attacked
Xuan Loc, 40 miles
(64 km) east of Saigon. The
North Vietnamese met fierce
resistance at Xuan Loc from the
ARVN 18th
Division. For two
bloody weeks, severe fighting
raged as the ARVN defenders made
a
last stand
to try to block the North
Vietnamese advance. By April 21,
however, the exhausted garrison
surrendered.
An
embittered and tearful President
Thieu resigned on the same day,
declaring that the United States
had betrayed South Vietnam. In a
scathing attack on the US, he
suggested U.S. Secretary of
State
Henry
Kissinger had tricked
him into signing the Paris peace
agreement two years ago,
promising military aid which
then failed to materialise.
"At
the time of the peace agreement
the United States agreed to
replace equipment on a
one-by-one basis," he said. "But
the United States did not keep
its word. Is an American's word
reliable these days?" He
continued, "The United States
did not keep its promise to help
us fight for freedom and it was
in the same fight that the
United States lost 50,000 of its
young men."[141]
He left for
Taiwan
on April 25, leaving control of
the government in the hands of
General
Duong Van
Minh. At the same
time, North Vietnamese tanks had
reached
Bien Hoa
and turned toward Saigon,
brushing aside isolated ARVN
units along the way.
By
the end of April, the Army of
the Republic of South Vietnam
had collapsed on all fronts.
Thousand of refugees streamed
southward, ahead of the main
communist onslaught. On April
27, 100,000 North Vietnamese
troops encircled Saigon. The
city was defended by about
30,000 ARVN troops. To hasten a
collapse and foment panic, the
VPA shelled the airport and
forced its closure. With the air
exit closed, large numbers of
civilians found that they had no
way out.
Back Top
Vietnamese civilians
scramble to board an
Air America
helicopter during
Operation Frequent
Wind.
-
Chaos, unrest, and panic broke
out as hysterical South
Vietnamese officials and
civilians scrambled to leave
Saigon.
Martial
law was declared.
American helicopters began
evacuating South Vietnamese,
U.S., and foreign nationals from
various parts of the city and
from the U.S. embassy compound.
Operation
Frequent Wind had
been delayed until the last
possible moment, because of U.S.
Ambassador
Graham
Martin's belief that
Saigon could be held and that a
political settlement could be
reached.
Schlesinger announced early in
the morning of April 29, 1975
the evacuation from
Saigon
by helicopter of the last U.S.
diplomatic, military, and
civilian personnel. Frequent
Wind was arguably the largest
helicopter evacuation in
history. It began on April 29,
in an atmosphere of desperation,
as hysterical crowds of
Vietnamese vied for limited
seats. Martin pleaded with
Washington to dispatch $700
million in emergency aid to
bolster the regime and help it
mobilize fresh military
reserves. But American public
opinion had soured on this
conflict halfway around the
world.
In
the U.S., South Vietnam was
perceived as doomed. President
Gerald
Ford gave a televised
speech on April 23, declaring an
end to the Vietnam War and all
U.S. aid. Frequent Wind
continued around the clock, as
North Vietnamese tanks breached
defenses on the outskirts of
Saigon. The song "White
Christmas" was
broadcast as the final signal
for withdrawal. In the early
morning hours of April 30, the
last
U.S.
Marines evacuated the
embassy by helicopter, as
civilians swamped the perimeter
and poured into the grounds.
Many of them had been employed
by the Americans and were left
to their fate.
On
April 30, 1975, VPA troops
overcame all resistance, quickly
capturing key buildings and
installations. A tank crashed
through the gates of the
Presidential Palace, and at
11:30 a.m. local time the NLF
flag was raised above it.
Thieu's successor, President
Duong Van
Minh, attempted to
surrender, but VPA officers
informed him that he had nothing
left to surrender. Minh then
issued his last command,
ordering all South Vietnamese
troops to lay down their arms.
The
Communists had attained their
goal: they had toppled the
Saigon regime. But the cost of
victory was high. In the past
decade alone, one Vietnamese in
every ten had been a casualty of
war—nearly a million and a half
killed, three million wounded.
By war's end, the
Vietnamese had been fighting
foreign involvement or
occupation (primarily by the
French, Chinese, Japanese,
British, and American
governments), for 116 years.[142]
Back Top
Events in Southeast Asia
-
Phnom Penh,
the capital of
Cambodia,
fell to the
Khmer
Rouge on April 17,
1975. Over the next four years,
the Khmer Rouge would enact a
genocidal policy that would kill
over 1/5 of all Cambodians.
The
last official American military
action in Southeast Asia
occurred on May 15, 1975.
Forty-one U.S. military
personnel were killed when the
Khmer Rouge seized a U.S.
merchant ship, the
SS
Mayagüez. The
episode became known as the
Mayagüez
incident.
The
Pathet Lao
overthrew the royalist
government of
Laos
in December 1975. They
established the
Lao
People's Democratic Republic.[143]
Tens
of thousands died and many fled
the country after being
released.
On
July 2, 1976, the
Socialist
Republic of Vietnam
was declared. After repeated
border clashes in 1978, Vietnam
invaded
Democratic
Kampuchea (Cambodia)
and ousted the Khmer Rouge.
Vietnam began to repress its
ethnic Chinese minority.
Thousands fled and the exodus of
the
boat
people began. In
1979, China invaded Vietnam and
the two countries fought a brief
border war, known as the
Third
Indochina War or the
Sino-Vietnamese War.
Back Top
In the post-war
era, Americans struggled to
absorb the lessons of the
military intervention.[144]
As General
Maxwell
Taylor, one of the
principal architects of the war,
noted "first, we didn't know
ourselves. We thought that we
were going into another
Korean war,
but this was a different
country. Secondly, we didn't
know our South Vietnamese
allies... And we knew less about
North Vietnam. Who was Ho Chi
Minh? Nobody really knew. So,
until we know the enemy and know
our allies and know ourselves,
we'd better keep out of this
kind of dirty business. It's
very dangerous."[145][146]
In the decades
since end of the conflict,
discussions have ensued as to
whether America's withdrawal was
a political defeat rather than
military defeat. Some have
suggested that "the
responsibility for the ultimate
failure of this policy
[America's withdrawal from
Vietnam] lies not with the men
who fought, but with those in
Congress..."[147]
Alternatively, the official
history of the
United
States Army noted
that "tactics
have often seemed to exist apart
from larger issues, strategies,
and objectives. Yet in Vietnam
the Army experienced tactical
success and strategic failure...
The... Vietnam War('s)... legacy
may be the lesson that unique
historical, political, cultural,
and social factors always
impinge on the military...
Success rests not only on
military progress but on
correctly analyzing the nature
of the particular conflict,
understanding the enemy's
strategy, and assessing the
strengths and weaknesses of
allies. A new humility and a new
sophistication may form the best
parts of a complex heritage left
to the Army by the long, bitter
war in Vietnam."[148]
U.S. Secretary of State
Henry
Kissinger wrote in a
secret memo to President Gerald
Ford that "in terms of military
tactics, we cannot help draw the
conclusion that our armed forces
are not suited to this kind of
war. Even the Special Forces who
had been designed for it could
not prevail."[149]
Even Secretary of Defense Robert
McNamara concluded that "the
achievement of a military
victory by U.S. forces in
Vietnam was indeed a dangerous
illusion."[150]
Doubts surfaced as to the
effectiveness of large-scale,
sustained bombing. As
Army Chief
of Staff
Harold K.
Johnson noted, "if
anything came out of Vietnam, it
was that air power couldn't do
the job.[151]
Even General William
Westmoreland admitted that the
bombing had been ineffective. As
he remarked, "I still doubt that
the North Vietnamese would have
relented."[151]
The inability to bomb Hanoi to
the bargaining table also
illustrated another U.S.
miscalculation. The North's
leadership was composed of
hardened communists who had been
fighting for independence for
thirty years. They had
successfully defeated the
French, and their tenacity as
both nationalists and communists
was formidable.
The withdrawal
from Vietnam called into
question U.S. Army doctrine.
Marine Corps
General
Victor Krulak heavily
criticised Westmoreland's
attrition
strategy, calling it "wasteful
of American lives... with small
likelihood of a successful
outcome."[151]
As well, doubts surfaced about
the ability of the military to
train foreign forces.[71]
The defeat also raised
disturbing questions about the
quality of the advice that was
given to successive presidents
by the Pentagon.[71]
As
the number of troops in Vietnam
increased, the financial burden
of the war grew. Some of the
rarely mentioned consequences of
the war were the budget cuts to
President Johnson's
Great
Society programs. As
defense spending and inflation
grew, Johnson was forced to
raise taxes. The
Republicans, however,
refused to vote for the
increases unless a $6 billion
cut was made to the
administration's social
programs.
Almost 3 million Americans
served in Vietnam. Between 1965
and 1973, the United States
spent $120 billion on the war
($700 billion in 2007 dollars).
This resulted in a large federal
budget deficit. The war
demonstrated that no power, not
even a superpower, has unlimited
strength and resources. But
perhaps most significantly, the
Vietnam War illustrated that
political will, as much as
material might, is a decisive
factor in the outcome of
conflicts.
In
1977, United States President
Jimmy
Carter granted a
full, complete and unconditional
pardon to all Vietnam-era
draft
evaders.[152]
The
Vietnam
War POW/MIA issue,
concerning the fate of U.S.
service personnel listed as
missing in
action, would persist
for many years after the war's
conclusion.
Back Top
People's Republic of China
In
1950, the
People's
Republic of China
extended diplomatic recognition
to the Vietminh's
Democratic
Republic of Vietnam
and sent weapons, as well as
military advisors led by Luo
Guibo to assist the Vietminh in
its war with the French. The
first draft of the 1954
Geneva
Accords was
negotiated by French Prime
Minister
Pierre
Mendes-France and
Chinese Premier
Zhou Enlai
who, fearing U.S. intervention,
urged the Vietminh to accept a
partition at the
17th
parallel.[153]
China's ability to aid the
Vietminh declined when Soviet
aid to China was reduced
following the end of the Korean
War (1953). Moreover, a divided
Vietnam posed less of a threat
to China. China provided
material and technical support
to the Vietnamese communists
worth hundreds of millions of
dollars. Chinese-supplied rice
allowed North Vietnam to pull
military-age men from the
paddies and imposed a universal
draft beginning in 1960. In the
summer of 1962,
Mao Zedong
agreed to supply Hanoi with
90,000 rifles and guns free of
charge. Starting in 1965, China
sent anti-aircraft units and
engineering battalions to North
Vietnam to repair the damage
caused by American bombing,
rebuild roads and railroads, and
to perform other engineering
works. This freed North
Vietnamese army units for combat
in the South. Between 1965 and
1970, over 320,000 Chinese
soldiers served in North
Vietnam. The peak was in 1967,
when 170,000 were stationed
there. Sino-Soviet tensions
soared after the Soviets invaded
Czechoslovakia in
August 1968. In October, the
Chinese demanded North Vietnam
cut relations with Moscow, but
Hanoi refused.[154]
The Chinese began to withdraw in
November 1968 in preparation for
a clash with the Soviets, which
occurred at
Zhenbao
Island in March 1969.
The Chinese also began financing
the
Khmer
Rouge as a
counterweight to the Vietnamese
communists at this time. China's
withdrawal from Vietnam was
completed in July 1970. The
Khmer Rouge launched ferocious
raids into Vietnam in 1975-78.
Vietnam responded with and an
invasion that toppled the Khmer
Rouge. In response, China
launched a brief, punitive
invasion
of Vietnam in 1979.
The two nations continued the
border wars in the 1980s, with
China capturing disputed islands
during the
Battle of
the Paracel Islands
and the
Spratly
Island Skirmish (1988).
South Korea
-
Further
information:
ROKMC#Vietnam War
On the
anti-communist side,
South
Korea had the
second-largest contingent of
foreign troops in South Vietnam
after the United States. South
Korea dispatched its first
troops in 1964. Large combat
battalions began arriving a year
later. South Korean troops
developed a reputation for
effectiveness. Koreans conducted
counterinsurgency operations so
well that American commanders
felt that Korean AOR (area of
responsibility) was the safest.[155]
This was further supported when
Vietcong documents captured
after the Tet Offensive warned
their compatriots to never
engage Koreans until full
victory is certain.[156][unreliable
source?]
Approximately 320,000 South
Korean soldiers were sent to
Vietnam. As with the United
States, soldiers served one
year. The maximum number of
South Korean troops peaked at
50,000. More than 5,000 South
Koreans were killed and 11,000
were injured in the war. All
troops were withdrawn in 1973.
Australia and New Zealand
An Australian
soldier in Vietnam
-
Australia and New Zealand, both
close allies of the United
States and members of the
Southeast
Asia Treaty Organization
(SEATO), sent ground troops to
Vietnam. Both nations had gained
experience in counterinsurgency
and jungle warfare during the
Malayan
Emergency.
Geographically close to Asia,
their governments subscribed to
the "Domino
Theory" of communist
expansion and felt that their
national security would be
threatened if communism spread
further in
Southeast
Asia.
Australia began by sending
advisers to Vietnam, the number
of which rose steadily until
1965, when combat troops were
committed. New Zealand began by
sending a detachment of
engineers and an artillery
battery, and then started
sending special forces and
regular infantry. Australia's
peak commitment was 7,672 combat
troops, New Zealand's 552. Most
of these soldiers served in the
1st
Australian Task Force,
a
brigade
group-type formation,
which was based in what was then
Phuoc Tuy
province, in the vicinity of
present-day
Ba
Ria-Vung Tau Province.
Australia re-introduced
conscription to
expand its armed forces in the
face of significant
public
opposition to the war.
Several Australian and New
Zealand units
were awarded U.S. unit citations
for their service in South
Vietnam, while the last
Victoria
Crosses—the highest
award for bravery in the
Commonwealth— awarded
to members of the Australian
armed forces were for actions in
Vietnam.[157][158]
Philippines
Some
10,450
Filipino
troops were dispatched to South
Vietnam. They were primarily
engaged in medical and other
civilian pacification projects.
These forces operated under the
designation PHLCAAG or
Philippines Civil Affairs
Assistance Group.
Thailand
Thai
Army formations, including the
"Queen's Cobra" battalion, saw
action in South Vietnam between
1965 and 1971. Thai forces saw
much more action in the covert
war in Laos between 1964 and
1972, though Thai regular
formations there were heavily
outnumbered by the irregular
"volunteers" of the
CIA-sponsored Police Aerial
Reconnaissance Units or PARU,
who carried out reconnaissance
activities on the western side
of the Ho Chi Minh Trail.
Soviet Union
The
Soviet
Union supplied North
Vietnam with medical supplies,
arms, tanks, planes,
helicopters, artillery,
anti-aircraft missiles and other
military equipment. Soviet crews
fired USSR-made
surface-to-air missiles
at the
B-52
bombers which were
the first raiders shot down over
Hanoi. Fewer than a dozen Soviet
citizens lost their lives in
this conflict. Following the
collapse of the Soviet Union in
1991,
Russian
officials acknowledged that the
Soviet Union had stationed up to
3,000 troops in Vietnam during
the war.[159]
North Korea
As a result of a
decision of the
Korean
Workers' Party in
October 1966, in early 1967,
North
Korea sent a fighter
squadron to North Vietnam to
back up the North Vietnamese
921st and 923rd fighter
squadrons defending Hanoi. They
stayed through 1968, and 200
pilots were reported to have
served.[160]
In addition, at least two
anti-aircraft artillery
regiments were sent as well.
North Korea also sent weapons,
ammunition and two million sets
of uniforms to their comrades in
North Vietnam.[161]
Kim Il
Sung is reported to
have told his pilots to "fight
in the war as if the Vietnamese
sky were their own".[162]
Canada and the ICC
-
Canadian,
Indian
and
Polish
troops (respectively,
representatives of
NATO,
non-aligned states,
and the
Warsaw
Pact) formed the
International Control Commission,
which was supposed to monitor
the 1954 ceasefire agreement.
Canada also had citizens serving
in Vietnam as part of the U.S.
armed forces and was a favored
destination for American
deserters,
conscientious objectors,
and
draft
dodgers during the
conflict. Canada hosted
30,000–90,000 Americans seeking
asylum.
Other countries
Spain sent
thirteen soldiers, including
doctors.[163]
Nicaragua[164]
and
Paraguay[165]
also offered to send troops to
Vietnam in support of the United
States.
Back Top
One of the most
controversial aspects of the
U.S. military effort in
Southeast Asia was the
widespread use of agents of
chemical
warfare between 1961
and 1971. They were used to
defoliate large parts of the
countryside. These chemicals
continue to change the
landscape, cause diseases and
birth defects, and poison the
food chain.[166]
Early in the American military
effort it was decided that since
the enemy were hiding their
activities under triple-canopy
jungle a useful first step might
be to defoliate certain areas.
This was especially true of
growth surrounding bases (both
large and small) in what became
known as
Operation
Ranch Hand.
Corporations like
Dow
Chemical and
Monsanto
were given the task of
developing herbicides for this
purpose. The
defoliants,
which were distributed in drums
marked with color-coded bands,
included the "Rainbow
Herbicides"—Agent
Pink,
Agent
Green,
Agent
Purple,
Agent Blue,
Agent
White, and, most
famously,
Agent
Orange, which
included
dioxin
as a by-product of its
manufacture. About 12 million
gallons (45 000 000 L) of Agent
Orange were sprayed over
Southeast Asia during the
American involvement. A prime
area of Ranch Hand operations
was in the
Mekong
Delta, where the U.S.
Navy patrol boats were
vulnerable to attack from the
undergrowth at the water's edge.
U.S. helicopter
spraying chemical
defoliants in the
Mekong Delta, South
Vietnam
In
1961 and 1962, the Kennedy
administration authorized the
use of chemicals to destroy rice
crops. Between 1961 and 1967,
the U.S. Air Force sprayed 20
million U.S. gallons
(75 700 000 L) of concentrated
herbicides over 6 million acres
(24 000 km2) of crops
and trees, affecting an
estimated 13% of South Vietnam's
land.
As of 2006, the
Vietnamese government estimates
that there are over 4,000,000
victims of dioxin poisoning in
Vietnam, although the United
States government denies any
conclusive scientific links
between Agent Orange and the
Vietnamese victims of dioxin
poisoning. In some areas of
southern Vietnam dioxin levels
remain at over 100 times the
accepted international standard.[167]
The
U.S. Veterans Administration has
listed
prostate
cancer,
respiratory cancers,
multiple
myeloma,
type II
diabetes,
Hodgkin’s
disease,
non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma,
soft
tissue sarcoma,
chloracne,
porphyria
cutanea tarda,
peripheral
neuropathy, and
spina
bifida in children of
veterans exposed to Agent
Orange. Although there has been
much discussion over whether the
use of these defoliants
constituted a violation of the
laws of war, the defoliants were
not considered weapons, since
exposure to them did not lead to
immediate death or
incapacitation.
Back Top
-
The
number of military and civilian
deaths from 1959 to 1975 is
debated. Some reports fail to
include the members of South
Vietnamese forces killed in the
final campaign, or the Royal Lao
Armed Forces, thousands of
Laotian and Thai irregulars, or
Laotian civilians who all
perished in the conflict. They
do not include the tens of
thousands of Cambodians killed
during the civil war or the
estimated one and one-half to
two million that perished in the
genocide
that followed
Khmer
Rouge victory, or the
fate of Laotian Royals and
civilians after the
Pathet Lao
assumed complete power in
Laos.
In 1995, the
Vietnamese government reported
that its military forces,
including the NLF, suffered 1.1
million dead and 600,000 wounded
during Hanoi's conflict with the
United States. Civilian deaths
were put at two million in the
North and South, and economic
reparations were
expected. Hanoi concealed the
figures during the war to avoid
demoralizing the population.[168]
Back Top
The
Vietnam War has been featured
heavily in television and films.
The war also influenced a
generation of musicians and
songwriters. The band
Country
Joe and the Fish
recorded
"I-Feel-Like-I'm-Fixin'-To-Die
Rag" in 1965, and it
became one of the most
influential anti-Vietnam protest
anthems. The musical
Miss
Saigon focuses on
the end of the war and its
aftermath. In cinema, noted
films that have shaped the
popular conception of the war
include
Apocalypse
Now,
Platoon,
The Deer
Hunter,
Hamburger
Hill,
Forrest
Gump,
Full Metal
Jacket,
Good
Morning, Vietnam,
Born on
the Fourth of July,
the
Rambo
films and
We Were
Soldiers, as well
as
Jacob's
Ladder. It serves
as the setting for numerous
video
games, such as
Battlefield Vietnam,
Conflict:
Vietnam, Elite
Warriors: Vietnam, The
Hell in Vietnam, Line of
Sight: Vietnam,
Men of
Valor,
Shellshock: Nam '67,
Vietcong
and its sequel
Vietcong 2,
and
Wings Over
Vietnam. It was
represented on television by the
series
Tour of
Duty. A common
misconception by people who were
not fans of the show is that the
media franchise
M*A*S*H
is set in the Vietnam War; it is
actually set in the
Korean War
theater. The TV series
China
Beach which aired
from 1988 to 1991 in the US
focused on the everyday lives of
the people sent to serve their
country. The Korean Horror film
R-Point
is set in the Vietnam war.
Back Top
|